Monday, November 21, 2005

Generosity Index and Voting Patterns

The table below is the 2005 version of the Generosity Index (data courtesy of the Catalogue for Philanthropy), with states colored red or blue based on their voting patterns in the 2004 election. In the interest of avoiding conflict on this blog, I will leave any (obvious, IMHO) conclusions about the political implications to the reader. What would be really interesting, I think, would be seeing if there were a correlation between personal religious commitment by state,and the generosity index. By eyeball, their appears to be a strong correlation between the strength of traditional Christian influence on society and the level of giving (Baptist Mississippi versus secular Massachusetts, for example), but I don't have any numbers to back that up.

StateHaving RankGiving RankRank RelationGenerosity Index
Mississippi506441
Arkansas465412
South Dakota449353
Oklahoma428344
Tennessee353325
Alabama387316
Louisiana4312317
Utah302288
South Carolina3913269
West Virginia48222610
Idaho41202111
Texas2241812
Nebraska34171713
North Dakota45291614
Wyoming1711615
North Carolina28161216
Kansas27151217
Florida2314918
Georgia1811719
Missouri3124720
Kentucky4033721
New Mexico4740722
Montana4945423
Indiana2931-224
Alaska2528-325
New York510-526
Iowa3642-627
Nevada1321-828
Ohio3244-1229
Maine3749-1230
California619-1331
Maryland418-1432
Washington1125-1433
Vermont3347-1434
Oregon2641-1535
Pennsylvania1934-1536
Virginia723-1637
Arizona2137-1638
Delaware1430-1639
Illinois926-1740
Michigan1635-1941
Hawaii2443-1942
Colorado1032-2243
Minnesota1236-2444
Connecticut127-2645
Wisconsin2046-2646
Rhode Island1550-3547
New Jersey238-3648
Massachusetts339-3649
New Hampshire848-4050